Should You List Your Windcrest Home During Light-Up Season?

In 2020, a Windcrest resident told the San Antonio Express-News that visitors had said seeing the holiday lights made them want to buy a home there. Every December, a Windcrest homeowner thinking about selling hears some version of that story and wonders whether this is the month to put out the sign. Thousands of cars roll past ranch houses lit up by their owners. A for-sale sign has never had a bigger audience.

What winter gives a seller is less competition. Across the San Antonio market, December is the month when the fewest sellers list their homes. A Windcrest home listed now meets fewer competing listings than it would at any point in spring. It also tends to sit longer and close at a smaller share of its original asking price. Choosing between Light-Up season and spring is a choice between those two costs.

December is when San Antonio sellers step back

The San Antonio Board of REALTORS counted 2,753 new listings in December 2025, a 14% drop from December 2024. From March through June 2026, new listings ran between 5,057 and 5,713 a month. So last December, about half as many new homes came on the market as in a typical spring month.

Buyers kept buying. The same December 2025 report shows 2,854 closed sales and 1,874 pending sales. From December 2025 through June 2026, December was the only month in which closed sales outnumbered new listings. The pendings show buyers writing offers in the same weeks Windcrest's streets fill with visitors.

January is different. New listings jumped to 4,235 that month while closed sales dropped to 1,974, the lowest count of the seven months. Seller competition picks up after New Year's, before the buyers come back in force. In this data, a seller's best stretch with the fewest rivals is December itself, and it ends when the lights go off.

What the thinner field costs

Each month below shows homes that sold that month, according to SABOR's monthly releases for December 2025 through June 2026.

Month New listings Closed sales Avg. days on market Share of original list price
Dec. 2025 2,753 2,854 92 91.2%
Jan. 2026 4,235 1,974 98 91.4%
Feb. 2026 4,018 2,363 102 91.9%
Mar. 2026 5,535 3,100 99 92.8%
Apr. 2026 5,713 3,135 87 93.3%
May 2026 5,101 3,637 83 92.7%
Jun. 2026 5,057 3,479 77 93.8%

The last column is where the cost of a thinner field shows up. Homes that sold from December through February closed at 91.2% to 91.9% of their first asking price. From March through June, that range was 92.7% to 93.8%. On a $300,000 list price, which is close to the area's October 2026 median, the gap between 91.2% and 93.8% is $7,800. These are market-wide averages, not a forecast for any one house. They do show that winter sellers as a group gave up more of their opening number.

Days on market tell the same story more slowly. Homes that sold in December had spent an average of 92 days on the market. By February the average was 102 days. If a home listed on Dec. 1 took 92 days to sell, it would reach that mark in early March. A Light-Up listing that sells at the average pace closes in spring anyway. The difference is that it spent December and January as one of fewer homes for sale.

This winter starts with more homes for sale than last winter

Last December's numbers came from a market with 5.25 months of inventory. SABOR's October 2026 report, released Nov. 10, puts the San Antonio area at 5.96 months of inventory. It also shows 2,524 sales for October, down 5% from October 2025, a $299,370 median price, 88 average days on market and 91.8% of original list price received. In Bexar County, the October 2026 median single-family price was $277,000 with 5.4 months of inventory.

Sellers this fall were already getting about the same share of their asking price that winter sellers got last year. A December 2026 listing goes into a market with more supply than December 2025 had. That makes the seasonal drop in new listings more valuable this year, because it removes rivals from a field that started out larger. It also makes the opening price matter more. Our October post on how San Antonio prices are falling during the listing rather than in the median covers why the first number on a listing has become the least reliable one.

Spring brings more buyers and more competing sellers

Waiting has a measurable payoff. The San Antonio Report reported in June that spring is typically the strongest season for home sales, and in May 2026 sellers received nearly 93% of original list price. Closed sales went from 1,974 in January to 3,637 in May.

Spring listings also have to compete with more homes. Active listings in the San Antonio area rose from 14,441 in December 2025 to 17,409 in June 2026, almost 3,000 more homes on the market at once. A spring buyer has more houses to choose from, and some of them are newer homes with builder pricing. Windcrest's ranch houses under mature oaks, as the San Antonio Report described the city, go up against all of that added inventory.

Winter tends to suit a seller whose house is ready now, who can wait out a 90-day average, and who would rather have fewer rivals than more buyers. Spring tends to suit a seller who needs the higher share of asking price and can live with more competition.

If you list during Light-Up, plan around the city's calendar

Windcrest has decorated for the holidays since 1959. As MySA tells it, founders Murray and Barbee Winn handed residents strips of lights and turned decorating into a friendly competition to put their new town on the map. A seller listing this season has a few dates to work around:

  1. Nov. 28, 11:59 p.m.: Deadline to register for the 2026 contest and Light-Up map. Categories include Best Use of Lights, Most Welcoming Front Porch and Best Street or Cul-de-sac.
  2. Dec. 1: Judging day for registered homes.
  3. Dec. 5, 2:30 to 6:30 p.m.: The Light-Up Kickoff & Market in the City Hall parking lot at 8601 Midcrown Dr.
  4. Dec. 13 and Dec. 17: The Light-Up Bake Off at the Civic Center from 4 to 6 p.m., and Light-Up Bike Night at 6 p.m. at 8101 Midcrown Dr.
  5. Jan. 1: The city's Light-Up FAQ says holiday lights stay on through this date. A Light-Up map is available at City Hall with the Windcrest Volunteer Fire Department.

That last date affects your marketing. Listing photos taken at dusk with the house lit up look great in December. After Jan. 1 they make the listing look old, and January is when new competition shows up. If you shoot lit exteriors, also shoot a daylight set you can swap in once the lights come down. Evening traffic on a Light-Up street also makes daytime showings the easier ones to schedule.

December's thin competition favors a house that is ready on Dec. 1. Our post on the sewer scope question for Windcrest sellers covers one pre-listing item worth settling first. For more on the tradition, see our guide to Windcrest's City of Lights.

If you are deciding between a Light-Up listing and a spring one, Melissa Boehringer can price your Windcrest home both ways, using the comparable sales an appraiser would pull, so you can see what each season would likely cost you. Schedule a free consultation, or start with a home valuation before the Nov. 28 map deadline.

Work With Melissa

Melissa can negotiate the best terms at the best price. For all your real estate needs, please don’t hesitate to give her a call!

Let's Connect